Diaspora Yeshiva Toras Yisrael | Mount Zion, Jerusalem

Home             About             Rabbis             Programs             Foundation             Contact

Home           About           Rabbis           Programs           Foundation           Contact

בס״ד

Diaspora Yeshiva Toras Yisrael

Torah From Zion

How to Learn Talmud: The Advantage of Ramchal's Method

April 26, 2018 / 18th of Nissan, 5784

By Rabbi Mordechai Goldstein, ztz”l
Founder of Diaspora Yeshiva Toras Yisrael
Chief Rabbi of Mount Zion, Jerusalem and King David’s Tomb

Rebbe HaRav Mordechai Goldstein Teaching Torah to Jewish Men

Rabbi Akiva's Success in Learning

Of all our great Sages, Rabbi Akiva is most noted for his meteoric ascent from total ignorance of the Torah to the greatest heights of learning. What was the secret of his extraordinary accomplishment? Rabbi Yehudah HaNassi revealed the answer to this mystery in Avos d’Rabbi Nossan (18:1).

Rabbi Yehudah HaNassi said of Rabbi Akiva, “He is a storehouse bursting with knowledge.” Rashi (Gittin 67a) describes this “storehouse” as analogous to “a large crate which is divided into compartmentalized boxes.” The secret to Rabbi Akiva’s success was his system of classifying and categorizing concepts and terms in a Torah thinking process with which he brought clarity to his vast knowledge.

This innovative process was not only of great benefit to himself, but also enabled his students to learn everything which he handed down to them from his teachers, incorporating all the work which he had done himself.

Conscious Learning

By recognizing the forms and structures that underlie the learning process, we have the tools for thinking and experiencing the Torah, which it is our privilege to learn. When the logical steps and abstractions of thinking are laid out in an open and honest way, there are endless insights and revelations, which wait to be uncovered in every word of Torah, like messages sent to us by HaShem Himself. Such a conscious awareness, by definition, must bring a dimension of excitement and vibrancy to our learning. For these insights are not parts of a mystique guarded only for the privileged few. Everyone one who devotes himself to the study of Torah must, by definition, produce his own novel insights. All that is required is that we follow the formulas and instructions of our Sages.

The Ramchal's Method

For many years, I was a student of HaGaon HaRav Henoch Leibowitz, ztz”l, who taught me the basis of lomdus and se’vora in Yeshivas Chafetz Chaim in Forest Hills, New York. Once, a new group of students came into the beis hamidrash and the great speed with which they became fully involved in all the ongoing debates made an impression on all of us. It was not long before I found out that their secret weapon was a small book called The Book of Logic, by Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto (Ramchal). At the time, this work was being studied in a chaburah with Rabbi Yehudah Davis, ztz”l, and my interest in their obviously useful and successful tool urged me to join in. That was the beginning of my involvement in methods of learning.

When I opened my own yeshiva, I continued to develop the idea of methods in learning — which are so helpful in cultivating the art of abstraction — in order to give my students a system for personal growth which I call “conscious learning.” In the opening verse of Mishlei, Shlomo HaMelech tells us that the Torah is for everyone’s development and growth. The Torah itself gives us the keys to understanding and the ability to change ourselves. Thus it is written (Mishlei 1:4-5), “It gives cleverness to the stupid, discretion to impetuous youth, knowledge to wise, and counsel to men of understanding.”

The advantage of the Ramchal’s work is that he has the stature and depth to distill the vast system of Talmudic dialectical debate into a small number of basic principles. A lamdan defines his value judgments in terms of distinctions between different abstract concepts or boxes, and the greater the man, the greater is the value of his boxes. The Ramchal was able to organize the entire system of dialectical debate and pilpul, and present a comprehensive understanding of its logical categories or boxes.

His method is handed down to us in three important books of which his Derech HaKodesh (The Way of Torah) is comprised:

The significance of the first book, The Ways of Reason, is that it provides the student with a Torah system of classification and categorization of conceptual ideas and terminology. These terms and methods are the “rings and handles” with which to acquire and handle Torah knowledge. The Ways of Reason gives us the tools, which will allow anyone who studies this method to apply the formula of our Sages of blessed memory and follow in Rabbi Akiva’s ways.

The Book of Logic, as a sequel to The Ways of Reason, represents a systematic effort by one of our Torah luminaries to distill the rabbinical method which is built into the foundations of Toras Moshe. It has proven to be very successful in the beis hamidrash. Students have been helped tremendously by this approach to learning Gemara, setting them on the path, with God’s help, to becoming talmidei chachomim.

Finally, in The Book of Words the Ramchal describes all of the rules governing communication of the mind and the will in his uniquely complete and orderly way. In the Gemara, these rules are constantly used by Chazal as signposts showing the points that our Rabbis saw as possible elements of weakness in our understanding. By making ourselves consciously aware of them, we have a definitive formula from Chazal that allows us to measure how successfully we have taken the chiddush of Chazal to heart.

Improve Your Abilities in Torah Thinking

Baruch HaShem Who has preserved us and brought us to this time to see from my student, Rabbi Dovid Sackton, the methods of Rabbi Moshe Chayim Luzzatto, one of our greatest “later authorities”, coming into the world in a pleasing and friendly form. My talmid has dedicated his efforts for almost thirty-five years to develop the methods of the Ramchal and to ignite and inspire the hearts of others. HaShem has blessed him with success as a Ram in the Yeshiva and with the merit to bring these works of the Ramchal to many students with purity of heart. The fruits of his labor are simple tools that students can master and apply, improving their abilities in Torah thinking.

It is my prayer that these gems go out from our beis hamidrash to the Torah world at large, and that Klal Yisrael reaps the benefits my students have gained from these works.

Adapted from the approbation and prefaces of HaRav Mordechai Goldstein, ztz”l, founder of Diaspora Yeshiva Torash Yisrael, to the translations of the three books included in Ramchal’s Derech HaKodesh (Way of Torah) in English and modern Hebrew by Rabbi Dovid Sackton and Rabbi Chaim Tscholkowsky, published by Feldheim Publishers.

Share This!

Come Learn Torah!

From beginner to advanced, if you’re a Jewish man, 18 to 35 years of age, and you’re ready to give your heart to HaShem, and to get serious about learning Torah, Diaspora Yeshiva has a place for you with us on Mount Zion, Jerusalem.